Black Powder in Spencer Carbine 44-40

Anything muzzle loading in here. Old and new, rifles, shotguns, pistols and even cannons!

Moderator: dromia

Message
Author
User avatar
Vossie
Posts: 274
Joined: Mon Oct 30, 2017 2:53 pm
Home club or Range: Bisley
Location: South East
Contact:

Re: Black Powder in Spencer Carbine 44-40

#1 Post by Vossie »

Edited, as my IT skills did its usual good


Hi my question is as I would like to shoot some black powder loads in the Spencer. Can I use the usual smokeless bullets,or are these to hard (GM bullets) or I cast pure lead, or can I replace the lube for a black powder lube.
I have yet to chamber cast this rifle, it is the Chiappa and not an original. and dont want to cast for another if I can help it, as about to embark on Martini Henry casting.

Cheers
Musclebob
Posts: 51
Joined: Sun Apr 10, 2016 9:26 pm
Location: Wairarapa, New Zealand
Contact:

Re: Black Powder in Spencer Carbine 44-40

#2 Post by Musclebob »

I can’t saw for sure about the Spencer, but if it’s anything like the Trapdoor, the hard lead bullets will cause more leading than soft cast. Also, the lube on the commercial cast bullets can combine with the BP to cause some really nasty fouling.

IMHO, your best bet is to cast your own from soft lead. Use a BP lube - make your own (I use a mix of unsalted vegetable lard and beeswax with a bit of olive oil to pan lube), or SPG is a very good, if not expensive option)
User avatar
dromia
Site Admin
Posts: 19964
Joined: Sat Nov 06, 2010 4:57 am
Home club or Range: The Highlands of Scotland. Cycling Proficiency 1964. Felton & District rifle club. Teesdale Pistol and Rifle club.
Location: Sutherland and Co Durham
Contact:

Re: Black Powder in Spencer Carbine 44-40

#3 Post by dromia »

When it comes to cast bullets hard is the last thing you want except some very extreme and specific cases.

Commercial cast bullets are hard for the manufacturers benefit only, harder alloys run better through the machines with better castability so less rejects also hard cast bullets travel better, soft bullets can get deformed in transit and need better packaging.

The only way to get a decent cast bullet is to make them yourself.

Petroleum based lubes are to be avoided with black powder as some can cause hard baking of the fouling making removal obstinate.
Image

Come on Bambi get some

Imperial Good Metric Bad
Analogue Good Digital Bad

Fecking stones

Real farmers don't need subsidies

Cow's farts matter!

For fine firearms and requisites visit

http://www.pukkabundhooks.com/
User avatar
Vossie
Posts: 274
Joined: Mon Oct 30, 2017 2:53 pm
Home club or Range: Bisley
Location: South East
Contact:

Re: Black Powder in Spencer Carbine 44-40

#4 Post by Vossie »

Excellent thank you for the advice, I do enjoy casting so it is not a problem.
I searched around and could not find this specific advice, so it is appreciated.

More time castings is time well spent.

Cheers
User avatar
Vossie
Posts: 274
Joined: Mon Oct 30, 2017 2:53 pm
Home club or Range: Bisley
Location: South East
Contact:

Re: Black Powder in Spencer Carbine 44-40

#5 Post by Vossie »

Would you add any tin to the mix, I use 10 parts lead to 1 part tin for my MH.
But pure lead for ML rifle and revolver.
FredB
Site Supporter Since 2019
Posts: 969
Joined: Fri Dec 10, 2010 8:33 pm
Home club or Range: stourport
Location: Wolverhampton
Contact:

Re: Black Powder in Spencer Carbine 44-40

#6 Post by FredB »

Much too much for a MH. 25:1 is plenty.
Pure lead for Snider.
Fred
User avatar
Vossie
Posts: 274
Joined: Mon Oct 30, 2017 2:53 pm
Home club or Range: Bisley
Location: South East
Contact:

Re: Black Powder in Spencer Carbine 44-40

#7 Post by Vossie »

Cheers Fred
User avatar
mikygpu
Posts: 87
Joined: Fri Jan 29, 2021 3:09 pm
Home club or Range: W&DRC, LCRPC, NRA, NSRA, FCSA, Bisley range, Lydd45 and other where I am permitted to shoot
Location: Hemel Hempstead

Re: Black Powder in Spencer Carbine 44-40

#8 Post by mikygpu »

I was wondering the same, except I have the ammo and not the rifle.
So is it black powder, nitro or smokeless?
Also I have 30-30 and some other undercover carbine ammo and I wasn't wondering the same.
Which rifle? How can you tell?
"The only true wisdom is in knowing you know nothing"
Socrates

I am here to learn!
Nobody was born knowledgeable...Except Jesus!
And maybe...just maybe...I might know something that some don't...like Romanian and Portuguese languages O:-)
Sfwh
Posts: 113
Joined: Fri Feb 28, 2020 11:59 am
Contact:

Re: Black Powder in Spencer Carbine 44-40

#9 Post by Sfwh »

Vossie wrote:Would you add any tin to the mix, I use 10 parts lead to 1 part tin for my MH.
But pure lead for ML rifle and revolver.
Historically the MH bullet was 12 parts lead to 1 part tin so I imagine that'll be the ratio that gets you the best results.
User avatar
dromia
Site Admin
Posts: 19964
Joined: Sat Nov 06, 2010 4:57 am
Home club or Range: The Highlands of Scotland. Cycling Proficiency 1964. Felton & District rifle club. Teesdale Pistol and Rifle club.
Location: Sutherland and Co Durham
Contact:

Re: Black Powder in Spencer Carbine 44-40

#10 Post by dromia »

Not necessarily, the miltary rounds have excessive tin added to toughen up the bullets for transport and field carry.

'Twas a trade of 'tween accuracy and logistical efficacy.

As civilian shooters we are not burdened by the exigencies of the miltary and comprimises so can develop accuracy loads frre of the miltary requirements. One of the many reasons why I use cast almost exclusively as it gives my better accurcay results in almost all situations than condom bullets that were developed for thier robustness in transpost, fieldd carry and going through automatic firearms.

My Martini Henry gives it best results with almost pure lead, just a smidgeon of tin to help fill out, both in paper patched and grease groove bullets.
Image

Come on Bambi get some

Imperial Good Metric Bad
Analogue Good Digital Bad

Fecking stones

Real farmers don't need subsidies

Cow's farts matter!

For fine firearms and requisites visit

http://www.pukkabundhooks.com/
Post Reply

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 8 guests