Salt Bath Annealing?
Moderator: dromia
Forum rules
All handloading data posted on Full-Bore UK from 23/2/2021 must reference the published pressure tested data it was sourced from, posts without such verification will be removed.
Any existing data without such a reference should be treated as suspect and not used.
Use reloading information posted here at your own risk. This forum (http://www.full-bore.co.uk) is not responsible for any property damage or personal injury as a consequence of using reloading data posted here, the information is individual members findings and observations only. Always verify the load data and be absolutely sure your firearm can handle the load, especially older ones. If in doubt start low and work your way up.
All handloading data posted on Full-Bore UK from 23/2/2021 must reference the published pressure tested data it was sourced from, posts without such verification will be removed.
Any existing data without such a reference should be treated as suspect and not used.
Use reloading information posted here at your own risk. This forum (http://www.full-bore.co.uk) is not responsible for any property damage or personal injury as a consequence of using reloading data posted here, the information is individual members findings and observations only. Always verify the load data and be absolutely sure your firearm can handle the load, especially older ones. If in doubt start low and work your way up.
Salt Bath Annealing?
Hi,
I have just read a few articles on the above, one article by The Gun Pimp I think
Has anyone else tried it?
Regards
Chris
I have just read a few articles on the above, one article by The Gun Pimp I think
Has anyone else tried it?
Regards
Chris
- Ovenpaa
- Site Supporter Since 2015
- Posts: 24680
- Joined: Fri Nov 05, 2010 8:27 pm
- Location: Årbjerg, Morsø DK
- Contact:
Re: Salt Bath Annealing?
I read the article myself quite recently and found it intriguing so I would also be interested to hear from anyone who has tried it.
-
- Site Supporter Since 2016
- Posts: 403
- Joined: Fri Nov 23, 2012 6:48 pm
- Home club or Range: NRA, Bisley
- Location: Egham, Surrey
- Contact:
Re: Salt Bath Annealing?
I've not tried it, but apparently it is used quite widely in industry for annealing.
While I'm not normally one for banging on about caution when trying something, as a chemist please make sure anyone thinking about this is aware of the hazards involved with it. As a technique it is certainly not without its risks. A molten salt bath contains a vast amount of stored up energy. Any water, oils, anything flammable etc gets into this and there is an explosion risk. Heat it up too high and the salts can break down and release some pretty nasty gases.
This is a link to a paper from 1982, about a lab in the US which was destroyed when one of these went wrong (granted a bigger one that most would use at home, but not a particularly high temperature);
https://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/cen-v060n041.p029
And a quote of the main points; "A University of California, Berkeley, lab has been rebuilt and is ready for use again after being demolished in late July by the explosion of a molten salt bath. Berkeley chemistry and chemical engineering faculty members are concerned that many researchers are unaware of the potential dangers of these commonly used heat-transfer media.
The explosion involved a glass polymer-synthesis apparatus immersed in a fused salt bath containing 3 lb of sodium nitrite and 1 lb of potassium thiocyanate. The bath had been heated above 270 °C using a hot plate. The experiment was being conducted in a closed fume hood.
The explosion, which Berkeley faculty members estimate had the force of about 1 lb of dynamite, caused more than $200,000 damage to the new lab. The doors of the fume hood were imbedded in a wall 20 feet from the point of explosion and the interior walls of the lab were bulged outward. "
While I'm not normally one for banging on about caution when trying something, as a chemist please make sure anyone thinking about this is aware of the hazards involved with it. As a technique it is certainly not without its risks. A molten salt bath contains a vast amount of stored up energy. Any water, oils, anything flammable etc gets into this and there is an explosion risk. Heat it up too high and the salts can break down and release some pretty nasty gases.
This is a link to a paper from 1982, about a lab in the US which was destroyed when one of these went wrong (granted a bigger one that most would use at home, but not a particularly high temperature);
https://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/cen-v060n041.p029
And a quote of the main points; "A University of California, Berkeley, lab has been rebuilt and is ready for use again after being demolished in late July by the explosion of a molten salt bath. Berkeley chemistry and chemical engineering faculty members are concerned that many researchers are unaware of the potential dangers of these commonly used heat-transfer media.
The explosion involved a glass polymer-synthesis apparatus immersed in a fused salt bath containing 3 lb of sodium nitrite and 1 lb of potassium thiocyanate. The bath had been heated above 270 °C using a hot plate. The experiment was being conducted in a closed fume hood.
The explosion, which Berkeley faculty members estimate had the force of about 1 lb of dynamite, caused more than $200,000 damage to the new lab. The doors of the fume hood were imbedded in a wall 20 feet from the point of explosion and the interior walls of the lab were bulged outward. "
- dromia
- Site Admin
- Posts: 19964
- Joined: Sat Nov 06, 2010 4:57 am
- Home club or Range: The Highlands of Scotland. Cycling Proficiency 1964. Felton & District rifle club. Teesdale Pistol and Rifle club.
- Location: Sutherland and Co Durham
- Contact:
Re: Salt Bath Annealing?
I played with it years ago when I was experimenting with molten lead annealing as well.
Besides the hazzards warning above, especially the one about it not getting over temperature a real risk in cheap non thermostatically/PID controlled pots like the Lee, I found the dipping process awkward to control for sufficient consistency. I am sure knacky people could rig up jigs and the like but that was just extra chew on for me. I find that a blow torch and a turntable to work just fine for me, simple and repeatable without the added hassle of watching pot temperature as well.
Also be aware that from my experience these salts are corrosive and hard on the pots and iron things around them.
Be worth looking at shipping as well, I got mine form a hot bluing materials supplier and I believe the bluing salts at least are expensive to send nowadays.
Besides the hazzards warning above, especially the one about it not getting over temperature a real risk in cheap non thermostatically/PID controlled pots like the Lee, I found the dipping process awkward to control for sufficient consistency. I am sure knacky people could rig up jigs and the like but that was just extra chew on for me. I find that a blow torch and a turntable to work just fine for me, simple and repeatable without the added hassle of watching pot temperature as well.
Also be aware that from my experience these salts are corrosive and hard on the pots and iron things around them.
Be worth looking at shipping as well, I got mine form a hot bluing materials supplier and I believe the bluing salts at least are expensive to send nowadays.
Come on Bambi get some
Imperial Good Metric Bad
Analogue Good Digital Bad
Fecking stones
Real farmers don't need subsidies
Cow's farts matter!
For fine firearms and requisites visit
http://www.pukkabundhooks.com/
-
- Posts: 1154
- Joined: Fri Dec 10, 2010 3:08 pm
- Contact:
Re: Salt Bath Annealing?
One or two Diggle members are now using salt bath annealing so I asked one of them to write up the process for Target Shooter.
It is certainly a bit cheaper to get set-up compared to the carousel/blow-torch type. As quite a few shooters already have melting pots for lead casting, it makes it even cheaper.
It is certainly a bit cheaper to get set-up compared to the carousel/blow-torch type. As quite a few shooters already have melting pots for lead casting, it makes it even cheaper.
- phaedra1106
- Past Supporter
- Posts: 3384
- Joined: Wed Feb 08, 2012 9:37 pm
- Location: Just outside Sacriston (the nice bit!)
- Contact:
Re: Salt Bath Annealing?
I have all the bits to do it, got a plate made to fit the small Lee pot etc.
I tried it once but the nasty high temperatures put me off!!!, I'll stick to my rotary annealer I got from Lubo on TSD :)
I tried it once but the nasty high temperatures put me off!!!, I'll stick to my rotary annealer I got from Lubo on TSD :)
There's room for all Gods creatures, next to the mash and gravy :)
Re: Salt Bath Annealing?
I have a PID and an old Lee Pot to use as a vestibule. Its the high temperature and the risk of an explosion puts me off
-
- Site Supporter Since 2019
- Posts: 969
- Joined: Fri Dec 10, 2010 8:33 pm
- Home club or Range: stourport
- Location: Wolverhampton
- Contact:
Re: Salt Bath Annealing?
I use a blow torch and a four inch nail in the chuck of a rechargeable drill. Some people, especially in the shooting game will do anything to make life more complicated.
Fred
Fred
-
- Posts: 1154
- Joined: Fri Dec 10, 2010 3:08 pm
- Contact:
Re: Salt Bath Annealing?
I call a blow-torch and a four inch nail in a drill complicated - can't get simpler than an AMP annealer.
- dromia
- Site Admin
- Posts: 19964
- Joined: Sat Nov 06, 2010 4:57 am
- Home club or Range: The Highlands of Scotland. Cycling Proficiency 1964. Felton & District rifle club. Teesdale Pistol and Rifle club.
- Location: Sutherland and Co Durham
- Contact:
Re: Salt Bath Annealing?
£1300 sounds complicated to me.
Come on Bambi get some
Imperial Good Metric Bad
Analogue Good Digital Bad
Fecking stones
Real farmers don't need subsidies
Cow's farts matter!
For fine firearms and requisites visit
http://www.pukkabundhooks.com/
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 8 guests