Noob question on moderators

New to the sport? Or just not sussed something out yet? Please ask your questions in here, there are many experienced shooters on the forum and someone will for sure come along and answer your question. This is a section for new shooters so if anyone can think of something please submit it.

Moderator: dromia

Message
Author
Odd Job
Posts: 297
Joined: Fri Jul 25, 2014 6:00 am
Location: London

Re: Noob question on moderators

#11 Post by Odd Job »

Some RFDs will refuse to sell a moderator unless it is proofed. I got into a heated discussion with one of them who had ordered me an ASE-Utra Dual Rimfire from Jackson Rifles and it arrived unproofed. He would not sell it to me until it was proofed and I had to absorb that cost.

I have numerous moderators, all in .22 and I have fired thousands of rounds through them. One of them is an unproofed A-TEC CMM4(6) which has had 12,500 rounds through it in the space of just under a year. I haven't cleaned it once, not even put any oil into it! It works just fine. That's a light-weight aluminium moderator. You can read how I am abusing it here:

https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/lead-dep ... 1-bertolli

The other type I have used extensively (with a high round count) is the ASE-Utra Dual Rimfire. I have one proofed and two others unproofed. It's more difficult to clean because all the baffles are stacked loose in the can. It is all steel, even the baffles.

Those two are quality moderators, roughly the same price. I think for ease of use, reduction in weight and all-round satisfaction I would choose the A-TEC CMM4(6) which is the one with 6 baffles. It is not meant to be opened: the recommendation is to spray some cleaner into it after each session.

For those two moderators, I can't see why they need to be proofed and I wouldn't buy those from an RFD who insisted they had to be! That's for .22LR...

I'm still waiting for someone to show me an unproofed moderator that was damaged, or caused damage to a shooter or a gun because of some defect in it which would have been detected at the proof house.

I'm willing to wager that all such incidents are more likely to be caused by an incorrectly-threaded barrel or other misalignment, rather than any pressure-related failure in the can.

However, some RFDs are worried that a buyer who has an "incident" with a moderator would then be able to take legal action against the RFD if the moderator was not proofed.

My advice is to find out what their stance is before you order, and if they say the .22 can must be proofed, then buy it elsewhere.
Good judgement comes from experience. Experience comes from bad judgement.
Odd Job
Posts: 297
Joined: Fri Jul 25, 2014 6:00 am
Location: London

Re: Noob question on moderators

#12 Post by Odd Job »

The other thing to be aware of, is some moderators are only offered in 1/2 x 20 threads. If you have 1/2 x 28 threads on your rifle, you will then need to get an adapter.
Good judgement comes from experience. Experience comes from bad judgement.
User avatar
kennyc
Posts: 2340
Joined: Wed Jul 20, 2011 11:21 pm
Home club or Range: hunters NRPC
Location: Reading West Berks
Contact:

Re: Noob question on moderators

#13 Post by kennyc »

SAK or the venerable Parker Hale will work perfectly well for .22LR I have a PH which is shared between .22LR and .22WMR , in a fit of enthusiasm I stripped it to clean it (after eating .22WMR for some time) I found the baffles in perfect condition and no sign of damage from the WMR, so I expect it to last awhile yet.
noise wise its perfectly acceptable, with subs the action makes more noise, and nothing is going to quieten the supersonic crack of HV or WMR rounds.
of course you can go for bragging rights and get a much mpre expensive mod, but don't expect a lot more performance, because it just aint there :D
User avatar
BamBam
Posts: 2695
Joined: Thu Dec 19, 2013 5:23 pm
Location: Royston vasey
Contact:

Re: Noob question on moderators

#14 Post by BamBam »

Odd Job wrote:The other thing to be aware of, is some moderators are only offered in 1/2 x 20 threads. If you have 1/2 x 28 threads on your rifle, you will then need to get an adapter.
I have an A-TEC Wave with 1/2x28 thread, it's an off the shelf item.
Image
Odd Job
Posts: 297
Joined: Fri Jul 25, 2014 6:00 am
Location: London

Re: Noob question on moderators

#15 Post by Odd Job »

Yep, you can get the A-TEC, ASE-Utra, Hausken and B&T in either thread.
But some others are only in 1/2 x 20, such as the Hogan Decimeater.
Good judgement comes from experience. Experience comes from bad judgement.
User avatar
Mattnall
Site Supporter Since 2016
Posts: 2858
Joined: Wed Mar 06, 2013 5:32 pm
Home club or Range: Harlow TAC, NRA, BSRC
Contact:

Re: Noob question on moderators

#16 Post by Mattnall »

IMHO one of the best mods for a 22LR is the Parker Hale MM1, great value (can be picked up for £10-£15 second hand) and seem to last a lifetime (or so the ones I have have, one over 40 years only with minimal cleaning).
I struggled to get one apart late last year and when it was finally in pieces I put it in the SS tumbler - I now have a very nice shiny stainless steel MM1. Looks great on a stainless barrel.

SAK are also good value for money, a little bit more expensive then the PH (not much) and a bit bigger diameter.
Arming the Country, one gun at a time.

Good deals with Paul101, Charlotte the flyer, majordisorder, Charlie Muggins, among others. Thanks everybody.
User avatar
RDC
Posts: 1145
Joined: Sun May 24, 2015 12:14 pm
Contact:

Re: Noob question on moderators

#17 Post by RDC »

I have a Parker Hale MM1 and to me, I personally find the A-Tec Wave to appear to be quieter. It's certainly solid though.
Post Reply

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 14 guests